| 14 Jun 2002 | Maya Jean | This drawing is just magnificient! The softness and smoothness of the different shades of warm colours, like fire, really render to perfection the image of this mystical bird. Simply wonderful, nothing else to add, really! | |
| 14 Jul 2002 | Riikka | It's beautiful! The colors look great against the black background. | |
| 19 Jul 2002 | Lulu Clarke | I can't decide between the to phoenixes(spelling??). I love them both =) | |
| 2 Aug 2002 | Nathan Neil Phillips | Well, the Pheonix picture is more easily seen because of how it frames the picture. The Firebird blends into its self a little bit, but once you look closer, it really draws you in. It also fills the space better than the Pheonix picture does. I like them both.  Roxanne Hancock replies: "Interesting analysis...thanks " | |
| 27 Aug 2002 | Rochelle Green | WEll I haven't seen the other one yet, coz I'm going through these in order, but I like this one. I think those yellow bits really bring the bird out. | |
| 8 Sep 2002 | Annie thatcher --smokey-- | i like both ^_^ but if i only have to pick one for a phoenix i would choose this one.. the other one is nice but it looks more purdy ((like a birdie)) then a phoenix ^_~ phoenix=cool bird=purdy theres my opinion  hehe still love both pics.. ^_^ *adores the way you use photoshop n stuff* | |
| 18 Jul 2003 | Laura 'Katsie' Yardeen | This is a very beautiful picture. I made as my portrait for a game I play called Furcadia and I have gotten many compliments for it (of course I do not claim it as mine! >.<  . | |
| 17 Mar 2006 | Anonymous | this is a lot better than phoenix #1. The only thing I'm not crazy about is, the pointed flame above its eye, looks like a beak. So to me the neck looks like its really distorted. Of course that same flame could be an ear, and thus it would be missing its beak - but the neck would appear to be more natural and less broken. Still pretty good though. | |
| 5 Oct 2006 | Janice | Beautiful..... flames, feathers, and water flowing into a mesmerizing glow. Love it. | |
| 23 Jul 2008 | Phoenix | I love this picture would I be able yo use it for the cover of my book  | |