| 2 Aug 1999 | René Brandt-Barr | If you want to do anything to the background, I'd personally sketch in some vague dark grey-blue shapes in the background to give it that underwater atmospheric perspective. Otherwise, it looks just fine as is  I love the tail. | |
| 2 Aug 1999 | Liz Chesterman | Oh she looks wonderful methinks. The coloring is great, and the tail design is wonderful. Glad to see you've colored this one. | |
| 4 Aug 1999 | Daniel Routhier | I like the sharp character contrasted with the blurry sea, and the coloring is pretty good too. | |
| 1 Feb 2000 | Liselle Angelique Awwal | So creative. The tail is beautiful. | |
| 18 Feb 2000 | Etak the Thivis/Kate Shenk | Oh wow, gotta love the tail.. | |
| 16 Jul 2000 | vince | Ah-ha! But the tail is vertical and I like to think of mermaids (actual mermaids) as a full-fledged mammal... so it really should be horizontal, souldn't it...
Just kidding... | |
| 23 Apr 2001 | eve | i liek yer version of mermaid taild better then other peoples..its unique..heh im odd i know... | |
| 4 Dec 2001 | Lucinda | The design is very nice. I think I preferred the uncolored version for one reason - while the body structure flows smoothly from fish to woman, the color doesn't. The sketch looked very smoothly entire - this is what she's supposed to be. The abrubt change of color makes her look like a grafted half fishy + half woman. She's just suddenly green (or peachy, depending on if you go from the top or bottom). As careful as you were to have her body flow smoothly, you should extend that same care to the coloration of her. You might also consider that as a merperson, she might not have a caucasian human hued torso - maybe her torso is also green? | |
| 25 Jun 2002 | Anonymous | ummmm, the tail is good, but the body is a little too...stretched. It looks like you drew it in a hurry. | |
| 8 Apr 2004 | Alfred Jodokes Kwak | I like her 'tail' or whatever you may call it...  | |