| 30 Dec 2001 | Jay | Gollum was bigger that that he was the size of gandalf. He had ears almost like a bat. And i want to say that he had claws. It is way off!!! | |
| 3 Jan 2002 | Ander | Remember Sam descibed him as having "paddle feet, like a swan's almost, only bigger". Oh, and miner gripe, either darken the background, or squint his eyes; like me, he has lived long in darkness. | |
| 22 Jul 2002 | Zanzer | Listen to me, young... sorry my poor English, I am from other world. Your intention was good, the draw was exceptional... but you didn´t capture the soul Gollum. Read once more the great Lord of the Rings. feel the magic, imagine all the details... and then let the pencil be your guide. Good bye... | |
| 1 Jan 2003 | Regina | No, no, no.. he´s too human-like here.. | |
| 11 Aug 2003 | Anonymous | Horrible! not at all like him!!! | |
| 23 Dec 2003 | Dream catcher | This is a very good pic of smeedle....He is just a poor hobbit with many broblem and a slight case of skitsofrantia  nice pic | |
| 26 Jan 2004 | Amy Lange | I think he looks more like Boo Radley (from To Kill a Mockingbird) than Gollum, but it's still a good picture. *looks and thinks* He really looks uncannily like Boo Radley. | |
| 13 Jun 2004 | Sara | Dream Catcher i hate to correct u but its Smeagol not smeedle
great pic by the way...to human though and i love the rest of your work | |
| 28 Jun 2004 | Bobby | Looks a little like my mother | |
| 22 Jul 2004 | Becca!! | oky doky, to all you dimwits out there who dont exactly kno that the books came before the movies a looong time ago and that the movies are HARDLY accurate, and who needa realize it FANTASY goshdarnit!!! v. v. good interpritation of smeagol/gollum btw... as are your others of him... honestly... in a place as inspiring as elfwood, we still get nimrods here... | |