| 28 May 2001 | Kirsten Taschira Scholz | I enjoy it. The face of Gandald could be a little .. softer. Don't know how to explain better what I mean. But it looks different than the soft surrounding. I'm glad you enjoy it! | |
| 9 Oct 2001 | Daniel Harris 'Hyptosis' | Cool comic! I've not read the book though, but your comic is very nice. | |
| 30 Mar 2002 | Paul Chris Pearson(Just call me Chris) | I've read that part and it says Pippin was laying in front of Gandalf.Of course great artwork.I agree with the other guy Gandalf's face should be softer (I mean it usualy is).But I realy liked reading it.This by far is the best yet I loved it.Later on I'll print it and tape it up on my wall next to my bed.Like I said before this is the best ever.Plus your the best artist I've ever seen artwork from. | |
| 2 Apr 2002 | Luthien | It's great to see so many Tolkien fans. I like the comic and u should make Gandalf look softer, but all in all it's a great comic!! | |
| 22 Apr 2002 | Nimrodel | I agree w/ the whole Gandalf should be softer thing. That's all. I'm not going to be picky and say that I thought Shadowfax was black. Because if I said that I would be getting too picky. | |
| 10 Jun 2002 | Brooke | Shadowfax was silvery white! not black! maybe in that stupid cartoon they made of it, but it was definately silvery white! I don't agree that the artist should make GAndalfs face softer, he is troubled at this point, and therefore, his look is appropriate, though I must say that his head is a little ... thin... it sorta looks like his brain has no room *sorry* if you add a little bit to the back of his head, you will be amazed at how much he changes! | |
| 30 May 2003 | Lúthien Tinúviel | Well, first of all I must say I enjoyed the comic, but I think there´s a big mistake. At that moment, Gandalf was Gandalf the White, no Gandalf the Gray!
Bye bye from Argentina! | |
| 11 Sep 2003 | Elven Maiden <elv | He was Gandalf the White, but here he is wearing a cloak. Right? ::looks doubtful for a moment:: Well, I read the others and he is wearing white. I like your idea, it reads from the book, which I like. My fave is the other one, where he is telling the guards that Pippin is brave, and pippin responds, "I am no more brave than I am a man, except maybe by necessity. Don't let Gandlf fool you!" One of my favorite parts of that book! | |
| 27 Sep 2003 | Blackbird | Well, Gandalf looks somehow a bit odd, but WOW how you managed to capture the cool night into that middle picture... You can almost feel it! | |
| 18 Sep 2006 | ≤BLAŞ | It was ok i think but if i was the guy i would make it beter lol | |