| 18 Feb 2004 | W. van Niekerk | wow! this is great! Great color use! really love the silmarillion...one tiny improvement point..the head might be a little too big, but other than that great picture! | |
| 18 Feb 2004 | Jessica Noelle Farwell | oh my God: this is beautiful. I am already an enormous fan or your art, and furthermore an enormous fan of Meadhros and every picture you draw of him. This is just...you really did capture the emotions you were aiming for. I love it. | |
| 21 Feb 2004 | Gilwen Finruin | I love it! I know what you mean about pesky elf muses -- Maedhros has been bugging me for a pic of him just before he jumps into the flaming crack in the earth: kneeling, the Silmaril blazing in his left hand, tears streaming down his face from the pain -- but I can't draw worth diddly *sob* Well, at least I can write fan fic about him.... | |
| 23 May 2004 | Dragon Faerie | the color and everything are perfect, love it, the only thing is that the arms are a little short for the body, (but that is really hard I know) other than that, perfect! | |
| 13 Nov 2004 | Dithat | His lips look a bit big, I think - if he's looking down, they should be thinned out even more. Other than that, love it. | |
| 6 Jan 2005 | kira | this is my favorite son of Feanor!! So proud and so modest at the same time, you draw him well, no negative comments. ^__^ | |
| 21 Jun 2005 | Tina | WOW!!!! He's gorgeous! I join the many people who say he is a big favourite of mine. Can't help but wonder what he'd think of having so many admirers, though! | |
| 12 Jan 2006 | Anna | Oh... Wooooow! This is very good ^___^ | |
| 4 Feb 2006 | Rinlachiel Galadhwen | Perfect. Absolutely perfect. | |