| 17 Jul 2006 | Valérie van Acquoy | Oh gee this is ALSO very impressive. It creates a great feeling (again!) about the battle-scene. It is a very impressive battle of course, but so is this pic! Great job! | |
| 23 Jul 2006 | The American | O_O whoaaaah..... | |
| 29 Jul 2006 | Anna Wedler | I´m absolutely speechless.... When I look at this pic, I feel like being right in there... Amazing. Perspective, colours, emotion... Everthing is just perfect. Keep up the brilliant work! | |
| 8 Aug 2006 | Ruuta Veigure | Wowww soo good picture!If "Lord of rings" had (they don't have) an illustration for battle at Helms,there were this picture! | |
| 12 Aug 2006 | Steffi | WOW!!! It´s fantastic! The environs is really gloomy. That´s all but I´m very impressed. (Sorry for this strange language but I can´t write good english, because I live in Germany) Yes, the picture is COOL! | |
| 26 May 2007 | Namiko Hitotsubashi | note to the commenter who commented about no illustrations for helm's deep, Alan Lee did do one. This is really impressive! | |
| 27 Jun 2007 | Katja Alakotila | Excellent piece! Love the lighting and poses. Excellent indeed...  Oo, and love the book as well...  | |
| 6 Dec 2007 | Joelle Duran | Fantastic! I especially like the point of view going here, gives a feel for how 'impregnable' the place was. Great lighting, too! | |
| 9 Dec 2007 | David Michael | Wow, great action shot! You've managed to capture much of the excitement, anxiety, and adrenaline of the battle, but from the orc viewpoint. My one criticism is that the causeway to the main gate looks far too steep. Other than that, though, it's excellent. | |