| 14 Feb 2004 | Trish *Bunny* Saw | That's gorgeous work, and don't let anyone tell you otherwise. | |
| 15 Mar 2004 | Elizabeth | Nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice!!!!!!!!!! | |
| 6 May 2004 | Charlie K | Great picture though i agree that it is a little dark and is hard to see clearly. you should lighten it slightly so we could see it better. | |
| 9 Aug 2004 | Your Pal Wormy | The point of the picture is to be dark. Because the Nine were EVIL. and evil is what again class? DARK! It's a beautiful picture and really shows what I expect Tolkein had in mind when he wrote the books. Lovely! | |
| 25 Jul 2005 | George Doutsiopoulos | By the Valar... I am speechless... This is perfect, you have really impressed. Scary and otherwordly, great lighting, great composition. Congrats! | |
| 27 Nov 2005 | Lauren Loveday | Should this not be in the fanartwork section.
And that is by no means a negative remark, it's beautiful. | |
| 9 Mar 2006 | Unknown soul | AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what a way to show the dispair and fright of the Ring Wraths.......creepy.....but awesome... | |
| 28 Oct 2007 | Terry .A. Ernest | Great Picture John...how about some new Artwork  | |
| 27 Feb 2008 | Heidi Hecht | It’s a shame about the lost detail but it’s a good picture from what I can see. And re: an above comment, it’s technically not "fan art" by the rules of this site if it’s based strictly on a book and not a movie. | |