| 1 May 2004 | Ariel Neimark | To me it doesn't matter whether she looks like the Galadriel I imagined or not, since everyone's mental image is so different anyway. It would be very strange if all artists depicted her (or the hobbits) exactly the same. So regardless of that, the picture is gorgeous. Perfect pencil coloring, wonderful tones, I love the facial expressions. And proportions seem pretty fine to me. Keep up the great work, and don't listen to flamers! If I had let other people's bad comments get me down, I wouldn't have dared to draw anything. | |
| 4 May 2004 | Jaknife | Umm, this is a great picture, but shouldn't it be in the FanQuarter? Nice job. | |
| 30 May 2004 | Elenian Tellumar | Try Arwen, I am sure you could do it. You should also try Eowyn killing the Lord of the Nazgul! | |
| 4 Jun 2004 | Matt Lucas | Tolkien would be proud. I have always loved Galadriel and you have portrayed her, in this setting, as I imagined her. Please stop by my gallery and let me know what you think of "Galadriel's Gift". | |
| 16 Jun 2004 | Justina Horvathova | Impossibly beautiful. | |
| 22 Jun 2004 | Cheyenne | Wonderful pic! I love the way her arms are out. It almost makes it seem like she's controlling what Frodo can see. I also love the color of her robes and how they flow about her. The moon creates an awesome effect! Very nicely done. | |
| 30 Sep 2004 | ELDORODWËN | ˇˇGENIAL!! Te recomiendo que tengas los libros y los leas. Además de ser una de las historias más maravillosas jamás contada es un motivo continuo de inspiración. ˇˇVIVA TOLKIEN!! | |
| 24 Jul 2006 | Sorcha | Did you use colored pencils for this? | |
| 13 Oct 2006 | Kay | ok I admit it i evy you i wish i where half as talented! | |
| 3 Jun 2008 | Oliver Greis | since i dont like photoshop coloring; i prefer true handmade drawings; i love this one. just got a fresh set of color pencils few weeks ago, again your work is very inspiring. | |