| 21 Nov 1998 | Franz Cheng | this piece has a lot of atmosphere | |
| 19 Jun 1999 | Incunabula | There is so much feeling in this piece. I can't stop looking at it! I guess it's just the look of serenity on his face that moves me so much. I'm quite impressed. | |
| 23 Oct 1999 | Tasha Kotraseva aka Isca Lox | This is sad. I like the mood of this piece. | |
| 7 Nov 1999 | Tinuviel | this is an awsome picture! very well done! except...
doesnt really look like bilbo..looks more like an
old chinese man......not a hobbit | |
| 13 Nov 1999 | Sutton | You can really see the warmth in this picture. | |
| 15 Sep 2000 | Julie R. Kowalski | all your pictures are very expressive, full of detail and totally free of over manipulation...they are simple and effective....so color me a rebel...i have to say it....WOW!!! | |
| 1 Jan 2001 | Nirgal | I always pictured hobbits to be chubby. Isn't he a bit emaciated? | |
| 5 Oct 2001 | Dewald Malan | It's a great picture... realy great But ahh... Hobbits dont look like this man!!! | |
| 4 Dec 2002 | Jamie Chang a.k.a. Ponine | You're probably sick of me saying over and over that your works 'have character', hahah, but you must know that in my view, this picture just screamed 'Bilbo' before I saw the title. | |