| 3 Mar 2006 | Jasna Bancak | Ovo bi stvarno voljela vidjeti u akvarelu! | |
| 29 May 2006 | Anonymous | This is a truly amazing picture, but wasn't it Maglor who got the last Silmaril and then cast it into the sea?  Latica Zekic replies: "They both got hold on Silmarils. But Maedhros casted himself into fire. I guess realization he has lost right to hold it was too hard..." | |
| 4 Sep 2008 | Anon. | The shading is wonderful--you can practically feel the light radiating from what he’s holding. However, the arm is slightly too long and there’s something not quite right about the slant of the nose. | |