| 26 Oct 2000 | Anon. | Woah for some reason i like it | |
| 3 Jan 2001 | Miikka Kulmala | uh.. i love this  the forest looks so deep and endless. | |
| 22 Jan 2001 | Theresa | This is really great but-and there always seems to be a but-her right arm(on top) should be a little thicker at the fold of the elbow...It's amazing otherwize, and black and white gives it a great effect! | |
| 24 May 2001 | Marianne (Anne) M. Forehand | I'm now posessed to read the Silmarillion. I wonder why. Good job. | |
| 26 Jan 2002 | Stephanie Zelerwitz | Someone should commit you to illustrate an edition of the Silmarillion! I absolutely love what you have done with her hair! | |
| 3 Sep 2002 | Mikael Hollsten | Nice work. Very atmospheric. I would like to see some stronger lines though and maybe some wood growth around it to give a framed effect to really catch the eye. All in all, very nice. | |
| 6 Mar 2003 | Ilye | Wonderful illustration of one of my fav tales from the Sil!!!!! It's absolutely beautiful!!!!!! | |
| 16 Sep 2006 | Anonymous | This has no shading or anything, yet somehow it is very powerful. Good. | |
| 30 Jan 2008 | Michael pixie john | another fabulous picture
poor creature looks so cold and shivery | |