| 23 Feb 2003 | Rebecca M. Roberts | Beautifull coloring! I really love it! Beautifull work! | |
| 23 Feb 2003 | Jonathan M. Snooks | Very Nice, The council of Elrond approves. | |
| 23 Feb 2003 | John R. Toohey | Wow! what beautiful colors, i love your technique, especially with the flowers. It seems like you did a wash and when it was still wet you added bloches of color to create the blossoms...true? I love your Knot-work as well, so intricate and complex! its very hard to keep knots consistant,straight and balanced...you've done an expert job, congrats! oh yeah, i do lord o' the rings art too..check it out! | |
| 26 Feb 2003 | Meyliene | I think this is a very good pic of Vana! I think the colors are great! Great detail and everything-Vana is my favorite character from the Silmarillion believe it or not. Very good keep up the great work.  | |
| 3 Apr 2003 | Míriel Lómendil <mlu0204@stu...se | Truly one of the better paintings I've seen of the sister of Kementári  | |
| 28 Mar 2004 | Morwen Celebrian Nolatari | Color... Overwhelming... Too much... Tone it down a bit. | |
| 13 Nov 2004 | Dithat | Something about her face - possibly the folds at her mouth - doesn't quite scream "ever-young" to me, but other than that, I like it. | |
| 16 Dec 2004 | Hanna Aakkonen | Wow, your watercoloring is awesome O_O | |
| 11 May 2005 | Merituuli | Are those gardens on the backround the lesser famous Vána's gardens? Muuten, hyvää työtä.Näen melkein samalla tavalla Morgothin vankeuden ajan ja Valinorin onnen ajan. | |
| 9 Jul 2008 | Krista | I love the colors you’ve used in your picture of Vana. They’re bright and youthful, which is perfect for Vana, the Ever-Young.  I salute you. | |