| 31 Jul 2006 | Nelleke Pieters | Really? I thought it was supposed to be the other way around   Magdalena Mantler replies: "I think you know what I meant by my reply! ;b Anyway, thanks!" | |
| 31 Jul 2006 | Nelleke Pieters | Beautiful!! The expressions are perfect, she looks so sad... And the background is beautiful!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "Oh, thanks so much for passing by! I´m very happy about that! And your comment makes me dance!! ^.^" | |
| 1 Aug 2006 | Nina Roussakova | Superb quality! Such a strong expression of emotion. Wow. Simply wow. I love the composition and the theme. The stained glass in the background really adds to it. And the choice of colours is excellent. A very strong piece!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "Oh I´m so glad to hear that!! It makes me really happy that give me so much compliments for this pic because I´m very proud of it. And to see that other people become deeply moved when they look at it is the greatest gift I could get! Thank you very much! ^.^" | |
| 7 Aug 2006 | Ramona C. Bogott | Thank you for your lovely comment on my picture. I wanted to come and check out your gallery and came across this lovely painting. I love how you put so much emotion into their faces. Excellent job! A very moving and powerful piece. So many beautiful colours in that window behind them. Really lovely all around!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "Oh, I have to say thank you!! But my pic is nothing compared to yours for your sister! But I would be glad if this pic also give you some hope and comforts you like your pic did to me... I wish your sister and you the best once more! And I would like to calm you both - maybe this pic can do... *wipes out teardrop again* " | |
| 13 Aug 2006 | Eva 'SMD' Stricker | *needs to fav* WOW!! *faints* This one is soooo gorgeous!!! You can almost taste their emotions. Wow.... Amazing job! ^.^  Magdalena Mantler replies: "*Reanimates her* Hope you didn´t hurt yourself while fainting! I´m very happy that you like it! Thanks for the compliment! ^.^" | |
| 22 Aug 2006 | Gregory D. Lyons | This is a beautiful illustration. I have to second the comment above, the woman on the left has a few anatomical mistakes, but overall the piece is so emotionally vivid it's really hard to crit. The lines and tone on the hand and throat of the woman on the right are just about perfect. Very strong piece.  Magdalena Mantler replies: "Oh, thank you so much! Yes I know about the mistakes - thanks for the critic! I´m very glad you like it!" | |
| 4 Feb 2007 | Annie Harrington | This is amazing! Wow, wow, wow. The style's so different from the other pictures in your gallery! I love the textures you achieved with the watercolors, and the skin tones are awesome! Yes, and as everyone has been saying. . . very moving. Excellent!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "Thank you SO MUCH for your comment!!!! (I´m very sorry that I´m so late...) It means so much to me!!!! Thanks!!" | |
| 6 Dec 2007 | Anonymous | This picture caught my attention instantly, it is so sad and yet has so much emotion in it, and it its so amazingly beautiful!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "I´m sorry for writing back so late … thank you very much that you feel the emotion in this pic, I´m glad that the emotion I lay into this pic really come out. ^^" | |
| 20 Nov 2008 | Silvia Meiliani |  This is very beautiful!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "O.O *blushes even more* you gave me so much nice comments … *blush*" | |
| 20 Nov 2008 | Sherri L. White | The compassion and tenderness from the black woman is so well shown you can feel it !!! wonderful job !!!  Magdalena Mantler replies: "*blushes and dances through the room in joy* you are too nice to me, really … but I´m so so happy you feel the emotions I layed into this picture!! *hugs you*" | |