| 24 Jul 2005 | John Ryan Byrd | Mythicalness is also on Crack, this is not amazing or great work, not close to being your best, Axe It. You can do much much better, and I think you know that. | |
| 1 Aug 2005 | Grace M. Amico | I guess John really doesn't have that ability to search through a picture, to find it's meaning, and to see the emotion which is dripping from this picture. The red agaisnt the grays is amazing, and it really does show how some guys think war is so noble and great, but they come back wondering how that thought could even come across their mind at all. IF they come back at all.  Lilleah Adora West replies: "yeah, i agreed with some of what he said, but frankly i think this one is one of my better images!!!!" | |
| 2 Oct 2005 | Reharalee | If anyone here is on crack, john, it's you. Yet again grace, i agree with you. | |
| 27 Oct 2005 | Alice | Incredible..this makes 2 of ur pics i have commented on...(means there good by the way) | |
| 20 Dec 2005 | Ally | This picture is amazing in my hometown in highschool I am in jrotc junior recruits of the army or sumthing like that lol sadly I don't know the name..I plan on join the active forces when I graduate and this picture has really touched me an scared me because I know everything is true I hate war but I would like to help bring it to an end...Your artwork is amazing | |
| 2 May 2006 | the Red Dragon (ashley) | It's beautiful...You know, in it's own way. i love the meaning behind this, and i love how disgusted the guy looks... it's so sad | |
| 20 Jun 2006 | Sammeh | NOTE- Please, everyone read this. Some other people besides John need to learn this information, too.
John, please, for the good of us all, just back away from Elfwood and go do something else. You are not a true artist if you can't learn to accept other's work. You need to shut your yap and spend some time working on your own gallery. Criticism is only good if it's constructive, not just offensive. You really need to realize that there ARE other artists with a lot more talent than you, and Lilleah Adora West is definitely one of them. | |
| 3 Aug 2006 | Raona | I feel what your feeling. I really hope they don't bring back the draft. It's bad enough my dad was chosen to go to war three times in less than three years. | |
| 31 Aug 2006 | Kikido-chan | *starts crying* AWWWWWW!!! That must be really bad!! | |
| 7 Feb 2008 | Désirée Ruth Dippenaar | This really conveys the terribleness of war! The contrast of the red against grey, black and white is really good. I like the lighting, and the clouds are well drawn too. Proportions are great! But I like best the meaning of this picture and the message - it comes across very strongly. I like the background story/description too, it is very powerful! War truly is senseless, and its time everyone noticed that! | |