| 12 Nov 2001 | Sam Weeks | Great!
I love it, u know, my name is Samwise William Weeks...
so i love the trilogy,a nd am very excited about the upcoming movie!
i have a new album i just recorded and wrote out named LOTHLORIEN, so i love it all too, glad to see someone is lovin it as much as me! keep up the good work! e-mail me sometime SamGamG899@yahoo.com | |
| 28 Dec 2001 | Dawna L Burke | I love the picture but I don't think it matches the text. I doubt Gandalf had time to sit down and light his pipe while facing the evil Balrog! "You cannot pass! I am a servant of the secret fire,... excuse me while I light my pipe and blow a few smoke rings... Oh yeah where was I? yes yes.. you cannot pass!" It looks more the scene where he was trying to think of every password possible to enter the mines of Moria, sat down to have a smoke and think while everyone else waited. I like the yellowed effect of the paper. Makes it look old.  Mauricio G. A. Silva replies: "My intention in ading that speech from the book was to characterize the personage by one of its most important scenes, same without making a closer scene-sketch relation. Sorry if it doesn´t work!! (there WILL be more drawings soon!)" | |
| 13 Jul 2002 | Hino Name | The monolouge would haveeven more effect if you had the balrog in the picture. | |
| 28 Aug 2002 | Nida | Great picture man. Maybe the text doesn't matsch the picture, but still I like it. Great work. | |
| 1 Jan 2003 | Tom m | Great captures his wiseness . But the staff is a bit small | |
| 25 Jan 2003 | Arwen Evenstar | The pic doesn't match the passage, but the drawing is good. I say to go with what you wrote, do more of a dramatic pose, like, on the bridge or something, and I agree with the other guy, have the Balrog in the pic. | |
| 2 Feb 2003 | Tolkien Junkie | I like this. It doesn't match the passage, but it is your interpretation, and as a fellow artist, I respect that. Keep up the good work | |