| 21 Jun 1999 | Cullyn | Like it............ | |
| 27 Oct 1999 | Shaggy-delic grrrlie | Whoa-- add some big ol ears and it'd be Yo-o-oda!! | |
| 2 Jul 2000 | Kim Van Gampelaere | Oh very special creature. I like the colors and the background. Thumbs up | |
| 24 Sep 2000 | Lisa R. *Luenetta* der Weduwe | ooohh... gotta luv gollum. all versions of him, esp. this one...  | |
| 14 Oct 2001 | Cairhien | looks better with colours, but it's still not quite right,(in my opinion) I always pictured him rather greyish, much as one would tend to be after not seeing the sun for that long. The background though, is really good! | |
| 11 Jan 2002 | Anonymous | I never read lord of the rings but i wonder if it is the same gollum that is in the hobbit. The hobbit is by the same writer. You ever read the hobbit or seen the movie? | |
| 15 Jan 2002 | Devy <BlueBoo15@aol...com> | Oooo. Very cool. I love the color scheme you have going. Looking at the comment above, is this the same Gollum from the Hobbit!? I'm reading it right now. Very good, just like your drawing! | |
| 26 Jul 2002 | Halo Black | Poor old Gollum. He doesn't look very happy does he? Maybe he needs a fish to cheer him up  Seriously, I love this piccy. I can honestly say this is one of the most Gollumish-Gollums I've seen so far  | |
| 24 Apr 2003 | Louie Peary aka Katz aka Aliaris aka Jeweled Dragon aka... | You fall into my sister's camp: people who think Gollum should be green. He isn't; the books in fact can't agree with themselves about whether he is black or whitish, but he certainly isn't green. | |
| 10 Aug 2004 | Heather ´Pixy´ Lynn | He's cute. He kinda looks like a baby Grim Reaper. | |