| 13 Jan 2004 | Christina Lee | Wow! This is just incredibly beautiful! ^_^ | |
| 18 Jan 2004 | Eruwen | This is SO beautiful, so magical. I feel as if I am there with her, and I keep expecting her to talk to me ...  | |
| 6 Feb 2004 | Tinuviel | Oh my gosh! This is so perfect! I love her name, that is why I took it as my web name, and now i have the perfect image to go with it! | |
| 10 Feb 2004 | Firewalker | No wonder why Beren fell in love with Thingols daughter. If she looked like this.... | |
| 9 Mar 2004 | Nimrodel | Oh, you can almost see her actually dancing. This is so beautiful. I love the sense of movement. Awesome job! | |
| 5 Apr 2004 | Undomiel | Beautiful picture, caught the movement and magic of the scene wonderfully! | |
| 2 Oct 2004 | Anonymous | Wow....! I can`t find the words... this is the best Lúthien picture I have ever seen!!!! Amazing!! | |
| 11 May 2007 | Julie | Though I have seen a lot of pictures depicted this very scene, I think this is by far the best, and it captures the everything I imagined on reading it. | |
| 9 Aug 2008 | Hannah | I think you’ve really captured this famous scene exactly how Tolkien (and I) saw it in his mind. I can actually feel the night breeze making the trees sway, and blowing Luthien’s starry mantle gently in the air, and like Jan said, if you listen really carefully, you can hear the piper playing as the Princess of Doriath dances under Varda’s stars, and as she is first beheld by her destined love, Beren, Son of Barahir. I will definitly check out the rest of your work, because these picture shows how really talented you are. | |