| 6 Jan 2000 | Alex j. Allen | this is a good job don't get me wrong, but it needs more realism,unless you want it that way, than scatch my comment | |
| 6 Jan 2000 | Jen R. DeFord | This is a very nice picture, but I think it needs color. You said it was a first attempt, so I'll look for it in the future!) | |
| 16 Jan 2000 | Kelly Krebbeks | I like this......adding color would be a nice touch....I found that those gel pens are great for adding color.....you get a smooth texture, and they blend nicely as well....but that's just my opinion | |
| 25 Feb 2000 | Jatta | This picture was very cute! I like it! (Don't know what more to write).... | |
| 19 Sep 2000 | Turambar | that is a horrible picture in my opinion, but i guess we all just invision Tolkien's characters in different ways... | |
| 1 Jan 2001 | Anon. | Shitty picture.Sorry but it's the truth. And you said it, your first attempt. It comes with time... | |
| 7 Feb 2001 | Giliath | My favourite character too. But there is nothing in your picture to make him an elf and not a human. Theres nothing that shows the kind of power and magesty he had...so...well keep at it anyway, i've tried to draw finglofin several times and incinerated the pictures after 2 minutes. Btw don't listen to Mr. "Shitty picture" commenter up there. Lets try some constructive criticism shall we? mutters something like "asshole" | |
| 6 Jun 2001 | Liska | I like it. The face is kind... I often see on the pictures elves having mean or grom exression... Your work is nothing like that! Thanks! (And hi from Moscow, Russia  ) | |
| 15 Jan 2003 | Luthien | I like your view of Fingolfin. It's interesting to see how other people envision their favorite Tolkien character. He's mine too! I really like your picture! Can't wait to see more!  | |