| 15 Jun 2004 | French Frog | Well done! He smiles... ah ah.. I like that.  | |
| 15 Jun 2004 | Ashley *Celesta* Versaggi | Very cute and dark at the same time. awesome, love it! ^_^ | |
| 13 Jul 2004 | KWINX | Adorable....not as dark as the third movie would lead you to believe. | |
| 7 Aug 2004 | Lena |  SO CUTE! so so cool! i love it too piecs *hugs him and wont let go* | |
| 31 Aug 2004 | Liz | This pic is awesome!!! I really love the style! Nice Job!  | |
| 10 Sep 2004 | Elvenwindmaster12 | *freaks out and runs for a drool bucket* | |
| 13 Jan 2005 | Ariana | I think his one eye is off a bit, but other than that, you're remarkable at drawing. | |
| 1 May 2005 | Lady_Voldemort | Not bad, except that shading under his nose makes him look a little like a monkey  . Like the smile, though - it looks just like one James would wear while contemplating a really mischievous trick... | |
| 26 May 2006 | Ashlee Matthews (Sparkle the Hedgehog) | He looks a bit like a frog... | |