| 28 Aug 1999 | Lynsey McGough |  I like the general composition... have read the book, and yes, recognised the scene. It's a little smudged ad faint in places (needs bolder, sharper lines!. Would be nice in colour. | |
| 14 Nov 1999 | Jen | Go Archchancellor!!!!! Yeah!!! Kill that compost heap! Vrey nice this is awesome, it looks the way i thought it would!!!!!!! you rock!!!!!1 | |
| 1 Mar 2000 | Stefan Fredriksson | Good picture ^.^ | |
| 19 Apr 2001 | C. T. O'Rourke | ROTFLMAO! It moves slowly and eats things; put a pointy hat on it and it could be a member of the faculty.  I love that quote. | |
| 16 Feb 2002 | Dog-gnuoy | I've never read the book, But i've played the game, and i have to say i like this pic. | |
| 31 Oct 2002 | Jimmy | *LOL* Look at the frightend wizards and witches! *LOL* | |
| 12 Oct 2003 | Sirius Skylighter | My gods this is funny. Ridcully throwing the bottle is just so...awww. You could maybe use stronger and clearer lines (now it has a sort of "unfinished" feeling all over) but apart from that it's a really great pic. Go you! | |
| 4 Jan 2007 | Kanelbulle | | |