| 17 Jul 2006 | Rebecca Jade Rundmann | Love it. So annoyed when Arwen took his part. Great Drawing  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "Thank you, thank you all." | |
| 21 Jul 2006 | Sheia | | |
| 31 Aug 2006 | Anonymous | Grr... I can't remember Arwen's dad's name for some reason... I watch LOTR all the time - I should know this... Anyway despite the fact their cartoon arwen's dad looks amazingly like... himself... not just cause of all the logo stuff that they where but his face... It takes a good cartoonist to make a cartoon of some one that actually LOOKS like them. Good job... Funny too  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "Elrond is his name. And yes, it is funny that it actually looks like him." | |
| 14 Sep 2006 | Marie Ludwig | I'm fond of this cartoon! Poor Arwen, she only wanted to help her beloved Aragorn...   Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "Some people just don't appreciate it!" | |
| 22 Jan 2007 | ChingMan Wong | It's about time someone pointed that out.  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "I think plenty of people have been pointing it out - have you seen some of the critic people put on the Net since the films came out? Phew!!" | |
| 21 Apr 2007 | Birdy | | |
| 8 Sep 2007 | Ruler of the bumblebees | Good picture, who’s glorfindel? *hides head in shame*  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "Go to the back of the class!! Or go to the Encyclopaedia of Arda website, for example, and read a few character bios " | |
| 30 Nov 2007 | Deborah Flyinghorse Sutherlin | LOL Thanks for the laugh Rachel! Poor Glorfindel.... he got completely ignored in the movie...but then so were many lovely LOTR characters! Misery loves company?  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "To be fair...there are a LOT of characters in LOTR and putting them all in would just have confused the viewers who don’t know the books and made the film at least an hour longer. " | |
| 30 Nov 2007 | KassiAnne Cox | | |
| 9 Feb 2008 | A. ~^*Skarbog*^~ den Hollander | hihi, this is so good..... let her be punished for what she did!  Rachel E. Johnstone replies: "Thank you. Daddy will make her pay, don’t worry about that." | |