| 13 Jul 2004 | Marina Romera | Oh my god! It´s perfect! It´s so real...Poor Haldir!! | |
| 7 Sep 2005 | Isilthien from Poland | *starts to cry* Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!! Not Haldir,not Haldir *sniff* :-( | |
| 8 Oct 2005 | Sidhenedon | Across the three movies there were a few scenes that made me cry either from grief or from the sheer adrenaline pumping glory of it all!! Haldirs death, the charge(s) of the rohirrim, the death of Theoden and the parting of the hobbits at the gray havens. | |
| 18 Oct 2005 | Elfdaughter | I like the way you've made the Uruck into a sort of shadow beind Haldir - it brings his moment of death into such more detail - fantastic! | |
| 6 Nov 2005 | Tigerlily | This is REALLY GOOD! I love how you captured the emotion in his eyes.  | |
| 17 Mar 2006 | Cassandra 'SilverWing' Cahill | ok for doing this from memory, it is so freakin good!!! poor Haldir, I'm so very sad that he died. he was such an awesome character! very good picture. | |
| 14 Aug 2006 | Shiregirl | You must have been very attached. It takes a very good and involved memory to do a scene like that from memory. Of course, the LoTR movies are good for that. They get imprinted in your mind. PoTC #1 also. I like the mouth. | |
| 31 May 2007 | Amanda | That was the only part of the movies I didn't like. ;-; Haldir... *clings to picture* | |
| 3 Sep 2007 | Darial | *looks around with teary eyes and comforts those who weeps* | |
| 29 Mar 2008 | Chamilia Lúthien Tinúviel | Haldir is not dead. The movies is okay, but I hate them couse Haldir is still alive! | |