| 2 Apr 2008 | Anon. | Fab idea, but try to slim them down a bit, they look a bit, um chunky  Gerlinde Dereik replies: "I meant for them to look a bit chubby, that’s how I imagined them when reading the books. I think it looks cute." | |
| 5 Apr 2008 | Olivia | So what if they’re "chunky"? There’s nothing wrong with that. Not everyone has to be super skinny. Honestly, I don’t even think they look very big. Really beautiful detail on the skirts. I like that they each have their own personality in this pic. Nice job!  Gerlinde Dereik replies: "thanks!" | |
| 10 May 2008 | Karoline "Potter" Haug | Very nice! but they’re a little bit ... eh.... fat. I don’t think parvati and patil is you know... chunky  It’s not how I imagine it, but nice!  Gerlinde Dereik replies: "haha, they áre a bit chunky, but that was on purpose. I don’t think everyone looks skinny (especially in high school where you go through a lot of changes) and I think they look great this way. thanks for your comment." | |