| 6 May 2004 | Tyler Meine | Loading...Awesome, atmospheric piece. I saw this the exact same way... Feanor, standing against a mighty enemy in what he had to know was a hopeless battle. That is valor, and you've captured it. Bravo. Alexander J. Harron replies: "You're too kind, really. I guess this was one of my favourite Tolkien moments, because the good guy loses. For some reason all the best Tolkien bits are when the good guy loses: Boromir dies, Gandalf falls, Frodo succumbs..." | |
| 16 May 2004 | Anonymous | Loading...Of all the images I have seen of Melkor (and i see alot), this captures the moment the best of all. I love the spikes on his back and the red mists, it truly shows his evil in the fullest. A very wonderful picture, this is what I will be seeing every time i think of Melkor now! Perfectly done, he looks just as the greatest Dark Lord should...scary! | |
| 18 May 2004 | Hobbit | Loading...wow! i just read this part the other day and you drew it about the exact same way i imagined it, except mine wasn't so red, it was darker. But I like the red much better, it fits well with the fight. I was very upset after reading this part. Poor fingolfin!
-hobbit | |
| 16 Jun 2004 | Justina Horvathova | Loading...*bows to your art* | |
| 6 Jul 2004 | Juddica | Loading...Oh, if you HAD to choose your favorite character from "The Silmarrillian" or any other Tolkein Novels, Who would it be? | |
| 6 Jul 2004 | Juddica | Loading...Melkor, *moment of silence* Truely my favorite being in any novel I have read. His power and might hidden in his dark robes which make him appear as the massive tower in which he broods... I see it as good that he doesn't have Gond out, Melkor with robes and Gond always look awkward... And if you drew showing Melkor's back and Fingolfin's face you wouldn't able to see Fingolfin, since Melkor towers over him ever so much. (Just defending illustrators from someone's post before mine...) | |
| 4 Nov 2005 | Anonymous | Loading...Wow!! Amazing. I really love this pic. Nice work. | |
| 29 Nov 2005 | Suzanne Mitts | Loading...This is the classic fight, fingolfin and melkor, i really love how you drew them, really captured them. Awesome. Whooo hooo! Must go read now *rustling of pages* | |
| 8 Jan 2007 | Anonymous | Loading...WOW!!!The greatest Melkor/morgoth-picture I have ever seen!!!OMG OMG!!!You could get gold-medal (with an silmarill) for this  !OMG OMG!!! | |