| 4 Jan 2004 | Margaret | Loading...Please, please do this one again, with the real Gollum posing (as he did so wonderfully in your Farimir farewell portrait) to help fill in the gap left by nassstycruel PJ who left this scene out entirely and even had the gall to replace it with...oh, I can't bear to say it. Sigh.I know exactly what you mean. | |
| 10 Jan 2004 | Silothiel | Loading...This is...amazing. I love this scene in the book, one of my favorites. You did a great job  Thanks. | |
| 22 Feb 2004 | Jenna | Loading...u know i like it but gollum looks like hes ready to bite ppor Frodo's u know what off..(dont wannt to spoil anything for other ppl who havent read/seen the movies) kinda scary..i wont try to comfort him again! *holds wrist..* left a scar u stupid creature! *resists urge to throw him over the side and watch him fall down the stairs* i like it!Don't be too harsh to poor Smeagol. He's not all bad. | |
| 30 Jan 2005 | Pendela | Loading...Hmm i really love sam and frodo in this pic, but i'm not too fond of smeagol either... | |
| 1 Feb 2005 | Quiet and shy | Loading...Oh, I hate what happens next in the book! All Sam waking up and driving Smeagol right back to where he was before. So sad. This is a wonderful depiction of the scene, though Gollum looks a tad to ferocious. Very nice, though! | |
| 14 Jun 2005 | Merrily Zerkaliun | Loading...The feet...Is..*shakes wildly* TOO HAIRY! (But everithing else is awsome!) | |
| 2 Oct 2005 | Grace Elizabeth Makley | Loading...I found this pic a long time ago when I was just beginning to get into elfwood, and I just found it again to show to a friend who's reading the books again and realised I never commented on it. This picture is absolutely beautiful, and inspiring. I had it on my desktop for a long time when I first discovered it; it portrays Frodo and Sam's relationship so well and is so sweet and sad. Your hobbits are the hobbity and realistic ones I have ever seen. Lovely. Thanks for such an awesome picture. | |
| 10 Nov 2005 | Margui | Loading...I like your picture Anke Katrin!! It's really heartbreaking. Poor baby!!  (Frodo). But is so sweet Sam is caring of him. | |
| 15 Aug 2006 | Liz | Loading...Aww, this is one of my favourite moments in the book. Sam puts Frodo's head in his lap, and strokes the hair away from his master's head. Adorable.
I'd just like to say, I really admire and love your style, it has a true Tolkien-like feeling to it. I don't care much for Gollum in this piece, he looks too evil. Which he really shouldn't do here. But otherwise, this is a fabulous picture. | |
| 15 Oct 2008 | Celebrian aka a hopeless tolkien fan | Loading...Oh this is my favoirte scene in the entire book! I can’t believe they took it out of the movie! i practically cried when i read it. the picture is really good, though! | |