| 27 Jan 2004 | Rosanna E. Hans | Loading...Nice. (Sorry I couldn't make a more constructive comment, hehe.) Joshua Doten Davids replies: "Thank ya, glad you liked them." | |
| 29 Mar 2004 | Red Orc Hord | Loading...I'll be as blunt as possible...totally sweet... Joshua Doten Davids replies: "Thank ya, they are some of my favorites some day in the future i will have to try those blade styles again." | |
| 23 May 2004 | Anonymous | Loading...I hate them, They would suck in combat Joshua Doten Davids replies: "Well not very constructive but in fact two of the designs great sword and claymore have been used quite successfully in combat the other two are pure fantasy designs with magic and demons in mind and not to be made in the real world, I did screw up on the pommel of one but that is why they say practice makes perfect and I have yet to be perfect in anything." | |
| 27 Aug 2004 | Patrick Leblanc | Loading...Awesome! I love the hiltless swords, great design! Joshua Doten Davids replies: "thank ya, these few were the first and won't be the last of hiltless swords i have others in the works but it will be some time before my next update." | |
| 10 Sep 2004 | Laura | Loading...Wow brilliant picture!! Imma go look at the rest!! Joshua Doten Davids replies: "Thank ya, hope you enjoyed your visit to my gallery" | |
| 29 Jun 2005 | Anonymous | Loading...Not bad drawings. the bottom two are the most realistic, but with the handles are to small. they would have to have strength in the upper most of the handle, or they would just double over, or assuming it was a scantly tempered handle, it would snap. also, the hilts are to wild and fantasy oriented, no cross-guard was ever made like that, for the reason simple reason that is would be damn near impossible, unless made by a machine. the top one wouldn't last a second, and I know someone already said this, but you could make it more realistic by adding a a large fuller, heavier pommel, and a wide, bowed handle. The second one wouldn't be a bad sword, but it would need a bowed handle, make it one handed instead of what looks like a 1 1/2 hand grip from traditional Irish and Scottish blades. Just thought I'd let you know. Nash, custom smith | |
| 11 Mar 2006 | The ultimate critic | Loading...Have you ever heard of shading??????????????? | |
| 14 Mar 2006 | Anonymous | Loading...I like the pics a lot. The top one doesnt actually remind me of Gattsu so much as it does of Fu Xi's sword from Dynasty Warriors. Gattsu's is more of a huge slab that doesnt even get slimmer as it goes on. Fu Xi's looks very similar to that, if not closely identical. Well, slash the extra designs. Great job, I would love to have something in real life resembling the top two. I'm just a big sword kinda guy. | |
| 13 Jan 2008 | Chris nangle | Loading...nice concept work.you may have figured out that Bonnie ann devlin is an idiot, and to ignore their opinions unless they are being constructive
| |
| 23 Aug 2011 | Anon. | Loading...Good work, I really, really like El Gathor! | |