| 3 Dec 2003 | Malva | Loading...I for one think that this is a very good portrayal of Caranthir. I can well recognize a hotheaded arrogant son of Feanor in him and the sharp features, I think, are very fitting. The hair is also very well done. As to the upper two comments, I would like to know where it is stated that Elrond is the only elf with long dark hair and that elves can't have prominent noses. Great picture! Good to see some Silmarillion character art ^___^ Helena Štěpánová replies: "Thank you. I only wish that there were not so much *movie* in it. (Though I love Peter Jackson's LotR movies...)" | |
| 3 Dec 2003 | Brianne Blitzcatt Hughes | Loading...Yea, I thought it looked a little like elrond too. Now that I see it close up it looks like either an elven snape or an elven aragon. Great work even though I may not see it for what you meant it to be. Helena Štěpánová replies: "Thanks... I appreciate it." | |
| 4 Dec 2003 | Michelle | Loading...Haha... for some reason, it reminds me a *tiny* bit of Davey Havok. Great work, I love the hair. Helena Štěpánová replies: "Do you? Gee, thanks... " | |
| 8 Dec 2003 | Hellga | Loading...Somewhat more evil and not quite as rosy-cheeked (his name literally means "ruddy face") as I like my favorite Noldo to be, but I guess not everyone likes him as irrationally as I do. *remembers her "Eight great Reasons to Love Caranthir* campaign* Helena Štěpánová replies: "I am into pale guys...;-))" | |
| 9 Jan 2004 | Dindae | Loading...Its wonderful, the first good picture of Caranthir I've seen.Sorry when I say I dont really like Caranthir himself.He's to cruel. Helena Štěpánová replies: "Thanks... " | |
| 10 Mar 2004 | Lindzi V. Sayles | Loading...Wow, he's really beautiful...i'll have to start drawing men like this but i don't think i could, i love his hair by the way. Helena Štěpánová replies: "Thank you very much..." | |
| 30 Jan 2005 | Karolina Sirielle Węgrzyn | Loading...Very good portrait, so handsome. Beautiful hair. Indeed Caranthir had a ruby complex of his mother but I guess he was really ruby in ager...And here he is not. IMHO he is so sharp and handsome that he could be Curufin  | |
| 3 May 2006 | Katherine V. Clements | Loading...I envy those of you who can draw a human male's face realistically, let alone an elf's! Bravo, I love it! I can see lots of character in his face, lovely shading and the hair is excellent! Helena Štěpánová replies: "Thank you..." | |
| 20 Aug 2006 | Caitlynn C. Didlick (Varda) | Loading...great job!!! I love it when I come across a real amazing Tolkien drawing! It makes my day! this is amazing!!! | |
| 23 Nov 2007 | Stephanie S. K. Marbach | Loading...Hi hair is great and his shading turned out perfect... Great facial expression, again  ! | |