| 10 Mar 2004 | Katie Slone | | |
| 14 Mar 2004 | Katie Slone | My AIM is AngstyLlama (just my AOL sn) but I'm not on that much since I've been busy lately. Ttyl hun  ://www.greatestjournal.com/users/me0wmix) <---my journal  Josiah 'Jos' Petroff replies: "*doesn't do the journal thing, lol*" | |
| 16 Mar 2004 | Jennica Fudge | Hm... interesting..... I like your work, it's really nice. I did a quick walk through, but it's obvious that you have a lot of talent. Keep up the good work!  Josiah 'Jos' Petroff replies: " thank you, and thanks for taking time to leave a comment." | |
| 22 Mar 2004 | Mandy ´Twin´ Elliott | I must admitt, you have great potential. Not much coming from me i know, but i do feel as though if you put a bit more passion in your work you could be one of the greats. It's clear to me that your strong point is in coloring and shading, somthing alot of people struggle with, myself included. Keep up the good work. I wish you well in the future. tom  Josiah 'Jos' Petroff replies: "I agree. I wish I could get lineart down better... but I can't lol.so! Thanks for leaving a comment and checking out my art " | |
| 24 Mar 2004 | Brad Schooley | Every time I come back to this gallery I am blown away. For real, I really love your art  btw like the profile pic too ^^ take care!  Josiah 'Jos' Petroff replies: "Thanks! Atleast I got you coming back XDthat means more than you know." | |
| 16 Apr 2004 | Elinor 'DiamondHoof' Jones | I love your art, you have true talent. Keep up the good work!! | |
| 28 May 2004 | Lea 'Oloriel' Zavodnik | I like your art, you're really good at drawing faces and the use of color is great.If anything needs improvement it's composition othervise it's perfect  | |
| 4 Jul 2004 | Jacqueline 'Sleepless' Kotowicz | Love your use of colors. I enjoy the Elfgirl pic....
"Keep sleeping!" | |
| 5 Jan 2005 | Josiah G. Harrist | Ha! Another Josiah on Elfwood! You definitely don't disgrace the name of Josiah, man, you've got some awesome skillz. Great job! | |
| 23 Oct 2005 | Anonymous | I love your art it's truly beautiful. I think u keep improving every time; keep up the good work. Another thing you are pretty cute, hope u keep posting new artwork, and hope to see more improvement. Q-What type of music do u listen 2?- i should go ttyl, sorry if it was an annoying comment. | |