| 12 Nov 2006 | Shane | | |
| 12 Nov 2006 | Anne Wipf | Very nice style. I particularly love your tigan. Just a small criticism : burs of the lead pencil on the white zone. Perhaps should you pulverize a fixative before scanner the image. Good work nevertheless. I hope to see more of your artwork soon.  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank you- Tigan's my favorite too! I always felt that my proportions were a tad bit off. I like the blur effect- I find it makes it look tattoo-like. Thank you for the helpful comments Anne!" | |
| 12 Nov 2006 | Emily 'Ameneko' Shults | You're in 8th grade?! Holy mackerel! How much have you done? You have some serious talent, skill, or both, Miss Bishop. Goodness. I'm very pleased to see someone your age ask for concrit. There are hundreds, probably thousands, of people who refuse it, and it's just pathetic. On that alone I think you could go far. Everybody I've seen who asked for concrit in the beginning got monumentally better as they got older, and you've got everything you need to become spectacular. Are you going to get a Wyvern's shelf at some point? Watch out for those First Publication Rights, but I'm interested in seeing some of your writing.  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank you Emily! You are very helpful when it comes to commenting! Yes, I am in 8th grade (whether I like it or not) and I am very pleased that you like my work. I think that at my level, I need criticism more than anything. I will probably get a Wyvern shelf so I can put short stories up for people to read. I will not put my book up though- I want to get it copyrighted before anyone reads it. ^-^" | |
| 12 Nov 2006 | James Helberg | I can see you have a very unique style. I actually find it pleasing to look at for it is different and original. I try to have a style, but alas, I have non. I hope to join you in Elfwood someday, but i don't have a good connection at home... Oh-well. Keep up the good work!  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank you!!! If you are on Elfwood even looking at pictures you must have style and taste! Just be patient (I know it's hard) and you'll eventually get an Elfwood page." | |
| 12 Nov 2006 | Stephen H. | Why only four pictures? For an 8th grader your pretty good. Better then I was. Better then I am probably. Keep up with your art and writing. Where your at now, I know your bound to do great things.  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank you so much for the comment Steve! I did four pictures because I was being impatient and I wanted to get an Elfwood page really badly. I had already done eight that the moderators refused (they said they were too Avatar: the Last Airbender like). I am working on more pictures to post. " | |
| 13 Nov 2006 | Kirsty 'Crisscoula' Yeomans | | |
| 13 Nov 2006 | John R Wenzel | Welcome to the Woods! Your gallery is off to a terrific start! I like your centaurs.  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank you John!" | |
| 19 Nov 2006 | Jasmin | Wow, I am amazed at the talent that you hold within you! I encourage the publishing of your book, and hope that it all goes well. Its pretty hard talking like that, don't you get tired of it? Just joking, you're great, and a great friend too!  Katherine J. Bishop replies: "Thank u Jaz." | |