| Date | Name | Comment | | | 4 Nov 2004 | Megan Proverbs | Loading..."Keep you shirt on" -- 'your' Oooh, what a great twist! Yes, the last sunset would be quite an amazing thing to see. Reminds me of something my dad says sometimes: "If the world's about to end, sit out on the balcony and watch the show." They seemed to arrive at Pluto awfully quickly, but this is billions of years in the future and they're aliens, so I'll put it down to some kind of remarkable transportation device that allows them to cross vast areas of space in a matter of seconds. Oh, and I love the idea of them using Pluto as a freezer, heheh! I think this would be stronger without a sequel, leaving people to work out the answers for themselves. But then, people said exactly the same thing about my story and I didn't listen to them...  Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Well I'm glad you liked it. I'll be editing all the typos sometime tomorow I think. Well I think I will write a sequal, I know it's going to detract from the 1st one but I think I can make it an exciting sort of adventure through space... I just love my characters!Oh well, if worse comes to worse, I'll delete any more chapters I write, but hopefully I can put a twist at the end of each chapter to keep that wow factor still going." | |
| 14 Dec 2004 | Charlene 'The Amazing Bubble Girl' M. Mattson | Loading...Wow, cool. I read it over twice cause I liked it so much. The revelation at the end was certainly unexpected. Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Gee thanks! Hopefully now you will read my other stories ... (nudge, nudge, hint, hint)." | |
| 4 Jan 2005 | Rachel 'Arrowfire' Morgan | Loading...Interesting story. Definately interesting. Oh, BTW... I have a new story up along with an update on my bats one.  Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "*Emma does not pass go and does not collect $200 as she runs off to Rachel's page*" | |
| 24 Jan 2005 | Deborah Cullins Smith | Loading...Good work, AGAIN, Emma. Nice twist. The sarcasm between your two characters is great. I know you can't describe them TOO much, but you might add a few details that could still be worded ambiguously... Like "... his broad shoulders pulling at the fabric of his shirt as he pulled back on the throttle..." or "... she brushed a stray lock of hair out of her eyes with an impatient hand." Somehow, we need to "see" the characters -- if nothing else, through their mannerisms. This way, we see the person, even if you aren't describing 9 foot green aliens with pointed heads! Keep up the good work! Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Manerisms, yes, I knew I was missing something.... usually for me it's missing more than one thing. Well thanks for the help, it's very much appreciated! " | |
| 5 May 2005 | Jkelley2 | Loading...Haha! This was excellent, especially considering how concise it was for the short size of the story. Are these actually "Martians" or just very confused Earthians?  This would be an interesting one to see continued. Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Not telling you the answer to that... aren't I so evil. Ummm.. and yes, it would be interesting to see continued but some people think that it would ruin it as this is a stand alone piece.But who knows what the future will bring." | |
| 29 Jun 2005 | Christabel Nolan | Loading...hmmm,,, a sunset on mars? that would be beautiful. a few minor suggestions (to get you back for all yours on my prologue, hehe) oh no, sorry, HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! *She wondered how it would all end;in fire, perhaps, as eddies and .....* - note insertion of semi colon and commas. *Since League* maybe capitals would make it less confusing? **Quit patronising me* full stop instead of comma?* hm. I hope that made sense. Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Thanks for the edits.. I've been meaning to go back through it and upload a better version.And yes, you did make sense! (a little sense anyway...)" | |
| 25 Jul 2005 | Max Hebditch | Loading...it's more powerful stand alone in my opinion and i have one question did you sneak in the “Yeah, they’re only guessing. The thing about stars that are about to *supernova* is that they are unpredictable.” bit just in case nobody understood. seems a tiny bit clumsy but most of my work has got little things like this that annoy me too Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Maybe I should re-word that line. 'Cause it's meant to sound patronising." | |
| 25 Oct 2005 | D. 'Yolaron' Hendrikson | Loading...I can't say much that others haven't, So I'll just repeat them. That was very good. And I like how you slipped in the names at the end, to catch us off guard... So what happens next? Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "*grins* Thanks... but do you really want to know what happens next? ^_^Oh ok, I'll finish of the next chapter and put it up. But some people think it should just be one short story... oh well!" | |
| 16 Nov 2005 | C. 'Liari' Seidel | Loading...Heh. Short, but cool. Liked it much, did I. *beams* I like sci-fi, I really do, and that was a nice twist. Whoo! Good job, good on ya, and good night! Ok, well, not good night, but you get the picture. Fwee! Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "Fwee! I like sci-fi too. It's cool and you get to do so many unexpected things with it! ^_^" | |
| 18 Oct 2006 | The Errant Sir Noah Landau 'Calrissian' | Loading...This is the sort of story that makes the genre great. It's not the popcorn/trash sci-fi, it's the meaningful stuff, and just like all good sci-fi, it packs a lot of meaning into a little space. I really think this should stand alone, so if I'm not too late and you didn't already write more, and if my vote means anything, I suggest you leave this to bask in it's own greatness. Any more will probably just detract from it. A little advice: I saw the ending coming as soon as the ruins on the next planet over were mentioned. If we had been made to think specifically that they were actually from Earth, something a little more than the mention of pluto, the end might hit harder. For example, from the beginning, the names already feel alien. Also the line about that not "really" being their home planet tipped the hand more than a little. I also think that using ruins as the device for introducing Earth gives away too much just a tad too early, since it introduces alien civilization in any case. Maybe something like meeting up with an exploration team or something, and then mentioning the water. I hope that all made sense, at least. Those are just my pieces of advice for some minor improvement on a story that really is the epitome of sci-fi. It's incredibly refreshing to find something like this, and I really must thank you for it. Thank you. Emma-Jane C. Smith replies: "WOW! What a compliment! ^_^ Thank YOU for leaving such a wonderful comment! *huggles!* I am now warm and fuzzy inside!" | |
| Page: [1] 2 |
|