| 3 Jun 2004 | Lufa | Loading...This is wonderful. I did think the movie massacred Treebeard somewhat but you've replaced that faith in Ents! Thanks. I'm glad you think so. 'Massacre' is a good word to describe the Ents' treatment in the movie. | |
| 10 Jun 2004 | Luinlainiel | Loading...Wow... great work!
so sad what they did to the ents in the movie. I mean, they've been there before the world was even made, so how would a 30yr old hobbit know more than them?
not that i dislike merry or anyhing, but its so depressing, what they did to bombadil, glorfindel, faramir etc.
BUT the battle scenes were good!
i do hope they do the hobbit, or have a go at the silmarillion. they would of course have to cut bits out, but i promise i wouldnt pay them ouit too much if it was ok!
*rambling again* sorry... i can talk about lotr for a long time... again, GREAT PIC!In my opinion PJ just made the Ents looks slow (which they are in the book) -- not in the wise 'non-hasty' manner that Tolkien wrote for them, but in the dumb, stupid kind. And that was a mistake. But anyway, thanks for the comment. | |
| 5 Aug 2004 | Eerin Vink | Loading...Its great! I am amazed by the beautiful shading and light-spots. It looks very natural.I'm glad you like it. | |
| 7 Jun 2005 | Ruth 'Cookie Monster' Browne | Loading...Treebeard! I really like him. Though not the movie version, not half as much as the book's. I have to admit, i enjoyed the "ents going to war" scene, even if it was entirely incorrect and they never sang the "boom, boom, etc." song, but you're right, they were made out to be rather thick. Annoying, that. You draw really well! *cookie_monster*Thank you very much indeed! Yes, I don't know. There was just something simply lacking with the portrayal of the Ents in the film -- just didn't seem to mix with the ancient majesty of the books so well. | |
| 14 Jun 2005 | Satya | Loading...This is a wonderful picture of a wonderful character from Tolkien's truly remarkable mythology. You are just so good at painting trees. I think that's why you have very skillfuly dealt with your rendition of Treebeard. The texture of his skin, hair and beard are superb. I can find no other words to describe But its his eyes that I really love! To me, they reflect not only the wisdom of the ages, but also his kindly nature and the mirth he was capable of, despite all the wrongs inflicted upon the forest. He looks as if he's giving some sound advice to some young sapling, or perhaps to one of the hobbits. My only critique, if I may, is actually very minor in my eyes. It isn't that apparent, but his right eye is lacking in eybrow whn compared to his left. But the rest of the picture makes me more than happy to ignore the fact. On the whole its an excellent depiction of everyone's favourite Ent! I think the main thing that's sorely lacking is a little yellow star on the top right-hand corner of the picture!  Ah, thank you once again my friend for the lengthy comment, as ever full of insight and praise that an artist can only ever dream of. It really is appreciated, beleive me. By the way, Satya. Remember that request you asked of me a long time ago? Well, it's finally finished, and in the ticket queue as I speak right now. I'm so sorry for taking as long on it as I did, but I'm so busy nowadays and have much less time for painting then I'd like. Anyway, I won't make you wait any longer -- here's a link to the painting, The White Rider. | |
| 26 Nov 2005 | Wood Elf | Loading... ) This one makes me smile This comment makes me smile. | |
| 15 Aug 2006 | Anime Freak | Loading...Treebeard was a fun character I really enjoyed. how he got along with Merry and Pippin so well made me smile. ha! I like this version of Treebeard. | |
| 10 May 2007 | Karen-Birgitte "Ellemerr" Borud | Loading...He's... Perfect! O.O | |
| 1 Nov 2008 | Steph Steph Salt | Loading...Hi Peter long time no see I hope the world is treating you well, remember Elfwood Brits?  it was good while it lasted huh? I decided to to follow this tour and just knew that one of your pieces would be listed  Treebeard here is stunning you go from strength to strength with your art. Keep well and sell my friend :* | |
| 5 Jun 2011 | Anon. | Loading...I like a lot of your work, but I think that you should reference more clearly that some of your paintings are studies / altered versions of Alan Lee artwork: http://celticmythpodshow.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/treebear- d.jpg
| |