"Animated Caleb Redesign?" by Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft

I think it's tight! And also very funny! (And please write something more than just "thanks")

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "I usually do write something else than thanks, if I feel that the comment has something that I can... Well, comment on. I don't really know what to say here, though. :/"

I'm not sure I understand it, but it's well done. The eyes are a bit strange, though, but I suppose it's your style. Very well done!

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "The joke more or less requires you to know both the comic and animation within a specific fandom. Unless you can point out exactly what you find strange, I'll write it off as my style as well. "

wow great job ^_^ very funny and i luv Caleb's expression haha

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "Thanks. "

hi, i dont hate the cartoon, but i still dont think its that good!
and by the way, someone said that there is no oracle in the cartoon, but its just because you dont see him until series 2.
plus blunk is not a goblin although everyone calls him a *smuggler*
i think they should have made caleb a former-murmerer/whisperer(whatever you call it), they just took away his identity!
in the comic yan lin is old and wise, in the cartoon she acts too immature for her age and doesnt die!
AND they keep elyon in the second series of the tv show, but the guardians are supposed to be cut off from meridian.
bye. xxx.

p.s: people in the UK who are looking for the w.i.t.c.h books, they sell them in WHSmith, and you can buy them online at amazon.co.uk!

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "Hehe, thanks for the info. I really d9on't have much to add, since my opinions should be pretty clear to all of your points. "

Lolz. Cool. ^^

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "Thanks. "

i dont know, W H I C H wasnt that bad a cartoon its certainly better then some of the more modden CGI or other imported cartoons that have been shown about lately .. and as a guy im not affaird to say i enjoyed the story line and i cant choose between irma or will as my fav charactures

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "When being used to the more mature early comic seasons, the first episodes of the cartoon are horrible. Never watched it again for the same reasons."

So true. The cartoons are okay but i love the comics way better. love the picture.

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "Thanks. "

I love that manga!

Rikke ´Gwennafran´ Loft replies: "The Japanese version that was discontinued, or the European comic that are somewhat manga inspired? "

funny! Im 16 and still read the comic every month

That made me so angry too! And the storyline changes. Though I guess i didn’t realise the show was targetted at kids not pre-teens/young teens. How would you explain a guy turning into a flower and it being kind of natural to a six-year-old?

But still. When my sister showed me the show I abandoned it entirely. It’s also not published in Australia so I miss out on heaps.

I love your drawing, by the way... just thought I should mention it... seeing as how that’s what I meant to comment on, not Disney and their... confusion, shall we say. From memory yours is quite accurate to the comic style, and the dialogue is amusing AS WELL as being in character, which is rare. Well done.