| 1 Jul 2005 | James A. Bianco | | |
| 2 Jul 2005 | Tomer Berman | All of your paintings are amazing, especially the one of Fingon and Thorondor, And also the one of Luthien (the colored one).  Stav Ofer aka 'Silmarien' replies: "hi Tomer! thanks for commenting, I forgot that you have an elfwood gallery!" | |
| 26 Jul 2005 | Avi O | Very nice gallery and beautiful pictures Brings you right into the fantasia worlds. I am proud to have the originals at home... | |
| 7 Aug 2005 | Vanessa Marsala | | |
| 10 Sep 2005 | Karin van Zon | 'ello! Got any updates coming??  Stav Ofer aka 'Silmarien' replies: "Hi! actually I've got a pending ticket right now (-: I suppose it will take about 7-10 days." | |
| 27 Sep 2005 | Karin van Zon | hehe comment form me again  I must say I loved your tour! And it's standing second in the Best overall score top 5 ( it was when I looked at it  ). Has your tour been in the queue for ages also?  Stav Ofer aka 'Silmarien' replies: "Hi! and thank you! well, my tour got it's 15 minutes of fame (or however you say that) but I didn't expect more . it's been in the queue since the beginning of July." | |
| 17 Oct 2005 | Constanza Ehrenhaus | Ok... ONLY six months!? well, then you do a very good artist! Still I think you should practice some more your anatomy, pay atention to muscles and how they run along the body, and also to hands and feet, which are very hard to draw. However your faces are sweet and lovely. Good job!  Stav Ofer aka 'Silmarien' replies: "Actually it's been a year now, since I joined elfwood some 6 month ago. I just updated my bio You're right about the anatomy, I need to overcome my laziness and pay more attention to it... thank you very much for your nice words, as well as your criticism!" | |
| 26 Nov 2005 | Ajder Andrei | thanks for stoping by my gallery and all, your art is preatty good as well... maybe work a bit on the backgrounds and shading ( I know that's a bit shalow... so if you want, I can go in to more detaill... ) but anyways, keep up the great artwork and good luck with future pics...  Stav Ofer aka 'Silmarien' replies: "thank you very much! if you have specific tips for me I'd really like to here them." | |
| 10 Dec 2005 | Linda Gock | | |
| 8 Aug 2006 | N. Rose Baker | | |